System and method for the secure transmission of data

ABSTRACT

A system for securely transmitting data includes a control device and at least one security module. The control device is configured for producing a cryptographic key using a physically unclonable function (PUF). The at least one security module is configured for communicating with the control device at least one of confidentially and authentically using the cryptographic key. The control device has no storage for storing the cryptographic key. The control device includes at least one hardware device that is configured for providing a specific feature combination. The control device also includes a calculation unit that is configured for producing the cryptographic key using the specific feature combination and the physically unclonable function (PUF). The control device further includes a program-controlled device that is configured for executing a first computer program product, which is configured for performing the encrypted/authenticated communication with the security module via a first and second communication interfaces.

CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This is a U.S. national stage of PCT Application No. PCT/EP2012/065010,filed on 1 Aug. 2012, which claims priority to German Patent ApplicationNo. 10 2011 081 421.3, filed on 23 Aug. 2011, each of which is herebyincorporated in its entirety by reference.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to a system for securely transmitting dataand to a method for securely transmitting data.

DESCRIPTION OF THE RELATED ART

In electronic systems that feature protected transmission of data,security modules are used today that perform the encryption and/orauthentication of data. To this end, these security modules are coupledto a control device of the electronic system via a protected data linkand interchange data with the control device, for example in encryptedform, so that a potential attacker cannot tap off the data in plain textwithin the electronic system before said data are cryptographicallyedited by the security module. If the data communication between thecontrol unit and the security module is not encrypted, an attacker couldsimultaneously read the data by simply eavesdropping on the datacommunication between the control device and the security module.Similar conclusions apply with regard to the integrity of the datacommunication between the control device and the security module.

If an existing electronic system, for example a control system for anautomation installation, that has no security module is intended to beextended by such a security module, for example when the hardware isrevised, the problem frequently arises that the control devices thathave been used in the electronic system prior to the revision of thehardware do not have a secure non-volatile memory that can be used tostore a secret key. If revision of the hardware now involves a securitymodule being provided in such an electronic system, a new communicationinterface is produced between the control device of the electronicsystem and the security module. Since a cryptographic key cannot bestored securely in the control device, encrypted communication betweenthe control device and the security module cannot be performed withoutdifficulty. The control device can communicate with the security moduleonly in unencrypted form. This makes it easier for an attacker toeavesdrop on this communication, however.

A flash memory that could permanently store a cryptographic key iscomplex to manufacture and cannot be miniaturized to the same extent asother semiconductor structures, such as transistors. Therefore, forreasons of cost, such electronic systems can rarely afford to have theircontrol device replaced with a control device having a securenon-volatile internal memory that could be used to securely store acryptographic key. For example, replacing the existing control devicewould result in complete revision of the hardware and the software ofthe electronic system and would therefore be very time consuming andcost intensive. In addition, the data integrity of flash memories has atime limit, e.g. 15 years, and flash memories have only a limited numberof write cycles, for example up to 1 million write cycles.

Instead of developing a complete revision of the hardware and softwarefor an electronic system, there are other ways to protect thecommunication between the control device and the security module. Tothis end, by way of example, the key for encrypted communication betweenthe control device and the security module can be stored in the computerprogram product, e.g. the firmware, that controls the communication withthe security module on the control device. However, suitable analysistools can be used to read a cryptographic key from a piece of firmware.

In order to prevent such reading of the cryptographic key, the firmwarecan be protected against what is known as reverse engineering. To thisend, a person skilled in the art is aware of what are known asobfuscation techniques. Such obfuscation techniques are limited in termsof the security level that can be achieved thereby and in terms of theexecution speed, however. In addition, the use of obfuscation techniquesincreases the size of the firmware and hence the memory requirement forstoring and executing the firmware by a multiple factor (e.g., factorsof 30 and more).

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

It is therefore an objective of the present invention to provide asimple way of protecting the communication between a control device anda security module.

The invention achieves this objective through systems and methods forsecurely transmitting data having the features as provided in theenclosed claims.

In one embodiment, a system for securely transmitting data having acontrol device and at least one security module produces a cryptographickey. The control device is configured for using a physically unclonablefunction (PUF). The security module(s) are configured for communicatingwith the control device confidentially and/or authentically on the basisof the cryptographic key produced. Notably, the control device does nothave an access-protected non-volatile memory for storing thecryptographic key.

In another embodiment, a method for securely transmitting data comprisesa step of producing, at a control device, a cryptographic key using aphysically unclonable function (PUF). The method also includes a step oftransmitting the data between the control device and a security moduleusing the cryptographic key.

The inventor of the present invention has recognized that a controldevice usually has hardware features that allow a cryptographic key tobe derived from these hardware features during the ongoing operation ofsuch a control device.

The present invention builds on the recognition by providing a controldevice that can use a physically unclonable function, also referred toas PUF, to derive a cryptographic key from hardware features of thecontrol device itself. Subsequently, this derived cryptographic key canbe used to encrypt and/or authenticate the communication between thecontrol device and a security module. In this way, the control devicedoes not need to permanently store the cryptographic key once produced,since the control device can derive the cryptographic key afresh eachtime the system is started, for example.

Physically unclonable functions (PUFs) can be used to derive a robustand explicit fingerprint for a given piece of hardware from minordifferences in the technical form of the hardware, particularly ofindividual integrated circuits. These small differences normally ariseautomatically in the fabrication of semiconductors as a result ofinevitable production tolerances. If required, however, such smallhardware differences can also be produced consciously during theproduction of a semiconductor. In a control device according to theinvention, these minor hardware differences are measured and convertedinto digital data, from which the control device then derives acryptographic key.

The present invention thus allows a cryptographic key to be provided ina control device but does not require the cryptographic key to be storedin a non-volatile memory. The cryptographic key is then taken as a basisfor performing encrypted and/or authentic communication. This not onlyreduces or avoids the requirement for use of non-volatile memory (e.g.,flash memory), but it also prevents a cryptographic key stored in suchmemory from being read by an attacker through hardware manipulations.

The use of a physically unclonable function (PUF) also has the advantagethat, in the event of an attempt by an attacker to manipulate thehardware, the hardware properties are changed such that reconstructionof the cryptographic key is no longer possible.

In the present invention, communication is understood to involve twoaspects of cryptography. Firstly, cryptographically protectedcommunication can mean the protection of the confidentiality of data,that is to say conventional encryption. Secondly, it also means theprotection of the integrity of data, e.g. using an electronic signatureor what is known as a “message authentication code”.

In particular, the present invention can be used advantageously inembedded systems, e.g. controllers for industrial installations, sincethere is an increased need for security in the latter on account of evermore significantly increasing threats from attackers.

Advantageous embodiments and developments of the systems and methodsaccording to the invention arise from the claims and from thedescription with reference to the figures.

In one embodiment, the control device has at least one hardware device,which is configured for providing a specific feature combination, and acalculation unit, which is configured for taking the provided specificfeature combination as a basis for producing the cryptographic key usingthe physically unclonable function, PUF. If a hardware device thatprovides a specific feature combination is provided, secure andrepeatable production of the cryptographic key becomes possible.

In one embodiment, the security module has an access-protectednon-volatile memory and a computation device, which is configured forreceiving the cryptographic key produced from the control device and tostore it in the non-volatile memory. This allows effective encryptionand/or authentication of the communication between the control deviceand the security module without the need for the control device totransmit the cryptographic key to the security module afresh after eachtime the system is started.

In one embodiment, the control device and the security module each has acommunication interface and are configured for using the communicationinterfaces to exchange data, wherein the control device is configuredfor initially providing the security module with the cryptographic keyvia the communication interfaces in an unencrypted data transmissionand, following the data transmission of the cryptographic key, tocommunicate with the security module in encrypted form and/orauthentically (or in authenticated form) on the basis of the transmittedcryptographic key. The security module is configured for using thecommunication interfaces to communicate initially with the controldevice in unencrypted form and, following the receipt of thecryptographic key, to communicate with the control device in encryptedform and/or authentically (or in authenticated form) on the basis of thereceived cryptographic key. This ensures that the control deviceexchanges just as much data as necessary with the security module usingunprotected communication. If the security module has received thecryptographic key from the control device, the communication thereaftertakes place only in encrypted form and/or authentically (or inauthenticated form).

In one embodiment, the security module is configured for receiving thecryptographic key from the control device only once and to store thereceived cryptographic key in the access-protected non-volatile memory,wherein the access-protected non-volatile memory is in write-once-onlyform and wherein the control device is configured for providing thecryptographic key for the security module only once.

The transmission of the cryptographic key from the control device to thesecurity module can take place in a suitable protected environment in aparticular production step during the manufacture of the system, forexample. In this case, the control device sends the security module thecryptographic key, e.g. in plain text, via the communication interface.The security module then stores the received cryptographic key in itsnon-volatile memory. At the same time, the security module locks itselfagainst the transmission of new cryptographic keys.

Similarly or alternatively, the control device can lock itself againstfresh transmission of the cryptographic key. That is to say that thecoupling of the control device to the security module can be performedprecisely a single time. Each time the system is started, the controldevice then derives the cryptographic key using the physicallyunclonable function (PUF), and the security module uses thecryptographic key stored in the non-volatile memory. Unprotectedcommunication between the control device and the security module nolonger takes place after this step of coupling. By way of example, in aproduction installation, a specific piece of firmware that allows thetransmission of the cryptographic key can be loaded into the controldevice. After the cryptographic key has been transmitted, the actualfunction firmware, which does not allow the transmission of thecryptographic key, can be loaded into the control device in theproduction installation.

This one-time coupling of the security module to the control device alsoprevents the misuse of the security module by a potential attacker onthe system. By way of example, it is not possible for the attacker toremove, e.g. unsolder, a coupled security module from a system andmisuse it.

In further embodiments, the security module is also equipped withsuitable hardware protection mechanisms that prevent the key from beingread from the non-volatile memory of the security module.

In one embodiment, the control device has a program-controlled device.In addition, a calculation unit may be arranged in theprogram-controlled device, wherein the program-controlled device isconfigured for executing a first computer program product, which isconfigured for performing the encrypted and/or authentic communicationwith the security module via the communication interfaces. In this case,the program-controlled device may be configured for executing furthercomputer program products, wherein the program-controlled device isconfigured for denying the further computer program products access to amemory that is used by the first computer program product for storingthe cryptographic key. This prevents an attacker from being able to loadmalware, for example, into the control device, which malware reads thecryptographic key directly from the respective memory area of the memoryof the control device and communicates it to the attacker, e.g. via afurther interface of the control device.

In one embodiment, the control device denies the further computerprogram products access to the memory that is used by the first computerprogram product by virtue of the control device using memory protectionmechanisms of what is known as a “memory management unit”. In a furtherembodiment, the control device also prevents what are known debuggingtools, such as JTAG systems, from accessing the memory that is used forthe first computer program product.

In one embodiment, the communication interfaces are in the form ofserial peripheral interface (SPI) interfaces and/or in the form of interintegrated circuit (I²C) interfaces and/or in the form digital parallelinterfaces and/or in the form of digital serial interfaces and/or in theform of a wireless interface and/or in the form of an optical interface.This allows flexible customization of the system to differentrequirements and areas of use.

In one embodiment, the computation device and/or the program-controlleddevice is/are in the form of a microcontroller and/or anapplication-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) and/or a programmablelogic chip and/or a computer and/or an embedded computer. This likewiseallows flexible customization of the system to different requirementsand areas of use.

In one embodiment, the hardware device is in the form of an internal RAMmemory of the control device and/or in the form of one or more delayloops and/or in the form of one or more ring-oscillators and/or in theform of two or more flipflops between which there is a cross-couplingand/or in the form of a line matrix in which the material in the lineinterspaces is randomly doped with dielectric particles and/or particleshaving non-reactive resistances. This allows the hardware device to beselected and customized to the respective intended use in accordancewith the respective application and the requirements of the useenvironment. In this case, in one embodiment, the hardwire device isintegrated in a housing with the control device or, as part of thecontrol device, with the latter in a housing.

In one embodiment, the specific feature combination of the hardwaredevice has transit times for individual gates of the hardware deviceand/or a turn-on behavior for individual components, particularly aturn-on pattern for an internal RAM memory, of the hardware device,particularly also for a processor cache of the control device, and/orresistive properties of the hardware device and/or capacitive propertiesof the hardware device and/or inductive properties of the hardwaredevice and/or frequencies of oscillators. This likewise allows thehardware device to be selected and customized to the respective intendeduse in accordance with the respective application and the requirementsof the use environment.

In one embodiment, the specific feature combination has the turn-onpattern of a RAM memory that is not automatically erased when the systemis started. In such an embodiment, the control device produces thecryptographic key directly after the system has been turned on.

The above embodiments and developments can be combined with one anotheras desired, provided that it is appropriate. Further possibleembodiments, developments and implementations of the invention alsocomprise combinations of features of the invention that are describedabove or below for the exemplary embodiments, which combinations are notexplicitly cited. In particular, a person skilled in the art would alsoadd individual aspects to the respective basic form of the presentinvention as improvements or additions.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The present invention is explained in more detail below with referenceto the exemplary embodiments that are indicated in the schematic figuresof the drawings, in which:

FIG. 1 shows a block diagram of an embodiment of a system according tothe invention;

FIG. 2 shows a flowchart for an embodiment of a method according to theinvention;

FIG. 3 shows a block diagram of a further embodiment of a systemaccording to the invention.

In the figures, elements and apparatuses that are the same or have thesame function have been provided—unless stated otherwise—with the samereference symbols/numerals.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

FIG. 1 shows a block diagram of an embodiment of a system 1 according tothe invention. The system 1 in FIG. 1 has a control device 2 that isconfigured to produce a cryptographic key 3 using a physicallyunclonable function (PUF). The control device 2 is also coupled to asecurity module 4. The communication between the control device 2 andthe security module 4 takes place in encrypted form and/or authentically(or in authenticated form). In this case, the encryption and/orauthentication of the communication between the control device 2 and thesecurity module 4 is based on the cryptographic key 3 produced by thecontrol device 2. This is shown in FIG. 1 by the connection between thecontrol device 2 and the security module 4 being used to performcommunication k on the basis of the cryptographic key 3, that is to sayk(3).

FIG. 2 shows a flowchart for an embodiment of a method according to theinvention. In a first step S1, a system 1 according to the invention isprovided. In a second step S2, a cryptographic key 3 is produced using aphysically unclonable function (PUF) in a control device 2. Finally, ina third step S3, communication takes place in encrypted form and/orauthentically (or in authenticated form) between the control device 2and a security module 4, on the basis of the cryptographic key 3produced.

FIG. 3 shows a block diagram of a further embodiment of a system 1according to the invention. The system 1 in FIG. 3 differs from thesystem 1 in FIG. 1 in that the control device 2 has a hardware device 5that provides a specific feature combination 6 for a calculation unit 7of a program-controlled device 14. The calculation unit 7 takes thespecific feature combination 6 and a physically unclonable function(PUF) as a basis for producing the cryptographic key 3. The controldevice 2 uses a communication interface 12 to communicate with thesecurity module 4 on the basis of the cryptographic key 3.

The security module 4 has a non-volatile memory 10 that the securitymodule 4 uses to store the cryptographic key 3. In addition, thesecurity module 4 has a computation device 11 that uses a communicationinterface 13 to communicate with the control device 2 and to receive thecryptographic key 3 from the control device 2. The computation device 11is also configured to store the cryptographic key 3 in the non-volatilememory 10.

The program-controlled device 14 of the control device 2 is in the formof a microcontroller 14. In this case, the calculation unit 7 is in theform of a computer program product 7 that is executed in addition tofurther computer program products in the microcontroller 14. In order toprevent the further computer program products from accessing the memoryof the microcontroller 14 that stores the cryptographic key 3, themicrocontroller 14 has what is known as a memory management unit. Thismemory management unit assigns a dedicated memory area to each computerprogram product and prevents a computer program product from accessing amemory area that is outside the memory area assigned to the respectivecomputer program product.

The hardware device 5 for the control device 2 is in the form of aprocessor cache 5 of the program-controlled device 14. The processorcache 5 forms, at the moment of turn-on, a characteristic turn-onpattern from which the cryptographic key is produced using thephysically unclonable function (PUF). In further embodiments, thehardware device 5 may be in the form of a specifically produced hardwaredevice 5, what is known as a unique/unclonable object.

In one embodiment of the security module 4, the non-volatile memory 10is in the form of a flash memory 10, and in further embodiments thenon-volatile memory 10 may be in the form of an EEPROM memory 10, in theform of an OTP NVM (one time programmable nonvolatile memory) 10 or thelike. In addition, the computation device 11 is in the form of amicrocontroller 11. In further embodiments, the computation device 11may be in the form of a security controller 11, in the form of an ASIC11, in the form of a filed-programmable gate array (FPGA) 11 or thelike.

In one embodiment, the security module 4 is in the form of a security ICthat is integrated with the control device 2 in an electronic system.Such a security module can be used, by way of example, in controllersfor industrial installations, e.g. programmable logic controllers(PLCs). In a further embodiment, the security module 4 may be in theform of a smartcard. Such a security module 4 can be used particularlyin pay TV applications, in person identification installations or thelike.

In the embodiment shown in FIG. 3, the communication interfaces 12, 13are in the form of SPI interfaces 12, 13. In further embodiments, thecommunication interfaces 12, 13 may be, by way of example, in the formof I²C interfaces 12, 13, in the form of USB interfaces 12, 13, in theform of serial interfaces 12, 13, in the form of parallel interfaces,12, 13, in the form of optical interfaces 12, 13, e.g. fiber opticinterfaces 12, 13, in the form of wireless communication interfaces 12,13 or the like.

In the embodiment shown in FIG. 3, the security module 4 is coupled tothe control device 2 in a production step during the production of anelectrical system. In this case, the control device 2 transmits thecryptographic key 3 to the security module 4. The latter then locksitself against fresh transmission of the cryptographic key 3.

Although the present invention has been described above with referenceto preferred exemplary embodiments, it is not limited thereto but rathercan be modified in a wide variety of ways. In particular, the inventioncan be altered or modified in multifarious ways without departing fromthe essence of the invention.

What is claimed is:
 1. A system for securely transmitting data,comprising: a control device configured to produce a cryptographic keybased on a physically unclonable function (PUF), the control devicecomprising: at least one hardware device configured to provide aspecific feature combination including frequencies of oscillators of thehardware device and at least one of capacitive properties of thehardware device and inductive properties of the hardware device, and acalculation unit configured to produce the cryptographic key using (A)the specific feature combination including the frequencies ofoscillators of the hardware device and at least one of (i) capacitiveproperties of the hardware device and (ii) inductive properties of thehardware device, and (B) the physically unclonable function (PUF); andat least one security module configured to communicate the transmitteddata to and from the control device at least one of confidentially andauthentically using the produced cryptographic key, wherein the controldevice has no storage for storing the cryptographic key.
 2. The systemof claim 1, wherein the control device further comprises aprogram-controlled device configured to execute a first computer programproduct, wherein the calculation unit is arranged in theprogram-controlled device, wherein the first computer program product isconfigured to perform at least one of the encrypted and authenticcommunication with the at least one security module via first and secondcommunication interfaces, wherein the program-controlled device isfurther configured to execute at least one further computer programproduct, and wherein the program-controlled device is further configuredto deny the at least one further computer program product access to amemory that is used by the first computer program product for storingthe cryptographic key.
 3. The system of claim 2, wherein the at leastone security module comprises a computation device, wherein at least oneof the computation device and the program-controlled device comprisesone of a microcontroller, an application specific integrated circuit(ASIC), a programmable logic chip, a computer and an embedded computer.4. The system of claim 2, wherein at least one of the first and secondcommunication interfaces comprises one of SPI interfaces, I2Cinterfaces, digital parallel interfaces, digital serial interfaces, awireless interface and an optical interface.
 5. The system of claim 1,wherein the at least one hardware device comprises one of (i) aninternal RAM memory of the control device, (ii) at least one delay loop,(iii) at least one ring oscillator, (iv) a plurality of flip-flopsincluding a cross coupling between each flip-flop of said plurality offlip-flops and (v) a line matrix in which a material in the lineinterspaces is randomly doped with at least one of dielectric particlesand particles having non-reactive resistances.
 6. The system of claim 1,wherein the specific feature combination of the hardware device furtherincludes at least one of transit times for individual gates of thehardware device, resistive properties of the hardware device, and a turnon behavior for individual components, including a turn on pattern foran internal RAM memory of the hardware device and a processor cache ofthe control device.
 7. The system of claim 1, wherein the at least onesecurity module comprises an access protected non-volatile memory and acomputation device, and wherein the computation device is configured toreceive the cryptographic key produced at the control device and forstoring the cryptographic key in the non-volatile memory.
 8. The systemof claim 7, wherein the at least one security module is configured toreceive the cryptographic key from the control device only once andconfigured to store the received cryptographic key in the accessprotected non-volatile memory, wherein the access protected non-volatilememory comprises a write once memory, and wherein the control device isconfigured to provide the cryptographic key for the security module onlyonce.
 9. The system of claim 1, wherein the control device includes afirst communication interface and the at least one security moduleincludes a second communication interface, wherein the control deviceand the at least one security module are configured to utilize the firstand second communication interfaces to exchange data, wherein thecontrol device is configured to provide the at least one security modulewith the cryptographic key via the first and second communicationinterfaces in an unencrypted data transmission and, following the datatransmission of the cryptographic key, such that communication with thesecurity module in at least one of encrypted form and authenticated formoccurs using the transmitted cryptographic key, and wherein the at leastone security module is configured to initially communicate with thecontrol device in unencrypted form using the first and secondcommunication interfaces and, following the receipt of the cryptographickey, such that communication with the control device in at least one ofencrypted form and authenticated form occurs using the receivedcryptographic key.
 10. A method for securely transmitting data,comprising: providing a system having a control device which includes nostorage for storing a cryptographic key and which includes at least onesecurity module; producing, at the control device, the cryptographic keybased on a physically unclonable function (PUF); and transmitting thedata from the control device to the at least one security module andfrom the at least one security module to the control device at least oneof confidentially and authentically based on the produced cryptographickey; wherein the control device comprises at least one hardware deviceconfigured to provide a specific feature combination includingfrequencies of oscillators of the hardware device and at least one ofcapacitive properties of the hardware device and inductive properties ofthe hardware device, and a calculation unit configured to produce thecryptographic key using (A) the specific feature combination includingthe frequencies of oscillators of the hardware device and at least oneof (i) the capacitive properties of the hardware device and (ii) theinductive properties of the hardware device, and (B) the physicallyunclonable function (PUF).
 11. The method of claim 10, wherein theproducing step comprises: providing a specific feature combination for ahardware device; and producing the cryptographic key using the providedspecific feature combination and the physically unclonable function(PUF).
 12. The method of claim 10, wherein the control device uses afirst communication interface and the at least one security module usesa second communication interface to exchange data, and wherein thetransmitting step comprises: transmitting, from the control device, thecryptographic key to the at least one security module via the first andsecond communication interfaces in an unencrypted data transmission; andsending data to the control device from the at least one security modulein at least one of encrypted form and authenticated form using thetransmitted cryptographic key following the transmission of thecryptographic key, wherein the at least one security module initiallycommunicates with the control device in unencrypted form.
 13. The methodof claim 10, further comprising: receiving, at the at least one securitymodule, the cryptographic key from the control device only once; andstoring the cryptographic key in an access-protected non-volatile memoryof the at least one security module.
 14. The method of claim 10, furthercomprising: executing, at the control device, a first computer programproduct that performs the encrypted transmission with the at least onesecurity module via at least one communication interface, and executing,at the control device, at least one further computer program product,wherein the control device denies the at least one further computerprogram product access to a memory that is used by the first computerprogram product to store the cryptographic key.
 15. A system forsecurely transmitting data, comprising: a control device configured toproduce a cryptographic key based on a physically unclonable function(PUF), the control device comprising: at least one hardware deviceconfigured to provide a specific feature combination includingfrequencies of oscillators of the hardware device and at least one of(i) capacitive properties of the hardware device, (ii) inductiveproperties of the hardware device (iii) and a turn on behavior forindividual components, including a turn on pattern for an internal RAMmemory of the hardware device, and a calculation unit configured toproduce the cryptographic key using (A) the specific feature combinationincluding the frequencies of oscillators of the hardware device and atleast one of (i) the capacitive properties of the hardware device, (ii)the inductive properties of the hardware device and (iii) the turn onbehavior for individual components, including the turn on pattern forthe internal RAM memory of the hardware device, and (B) the physicallyunclonable function (PUF); and at least one security module configuredto communicate the transmitted data to and from the control device atleast one of confidentially and authentically using the producedcryptographic key, wherein the control device has no storage for storingthe cryptographic key.